In a meeting when the new client rings: a calls plan for law firms and accountants

New matters start with a phone call, and most arrive while you are with a client. How small firms can catch those calls without leaving the meeting.

Every new matter starts with a phone call. Someone has a contract dispute, a property settlement, a tax problem or a business to set up, and they ring a firm. Very often, the person they need is in a meeting, on another call or in court.

In a large firm, reception picks up. In a small practice, the phone often rings out or goes to voicemail. And a new client with a pressing problem rarely leaves a detailed voicemail. They ring the next firm on the list.

Here is how solicitors, conveyancers and accountants can make sure the calls they cannot take still become new work.

Why missed calls cost professional firms so much

You bill by the hour, and you cannot bill for answering the phone. Stepping out of a client meeting to take a call is bad for the client in front of you. Not taking it can mean losing the next one.

The calls you miss are often the valuable ones. A new enquiry usually comes from someone who has just decided they need help: a letter has arrived, a deadline has been set, a settlement date is looming. They want to talk to someone soon, and the first firm that responds properly has the advantage.

Existing clients matter too. A client who rings twice and gets voicemail both times starts to wonder whether their matter is getting the attention it deserves.

Sort calls before you return them

Most calls to a small firm fall into a few groups:

  • New enquiries. Someone with a matter who has not worked with you before. The most valuable call, and often the most time-sensitive.
  • Existing clients. Questions about a current matter, documents, or next steps.
  • Other professionals. Other firms, agents, brokers, the court or a government office.
  • Sales calls. Software, marketing, directory listings.

Each needs a different response. A new enquiry with a deadline next week should be returned today. A sales call does not need to be returned at all.

The questions to ask every caller

Whoever answers for you should ask the same few things every time:

  1. What is the nature of your enquiry?
  2. Are you an existing client?
  3. Is this time-sensitive?
  4. What is the best time and number for a callback?

That is enough to sort the call and to return it with context. You do not need the full story on the first call, and the caller should not be asked to tell it twice.

One rule is non-negotiable: whoever answers should never give legal or financial advice. They take the message and tell the caller someone will be in touch. Make that an explicit instruction, whether your receptionist is a person or an AI.

What happens while you are with a client

Your phone still rings first. If you or a colleague can answer it, you do. If not, AfterTone answers professionally, asks your questions and emails you a summary within about a minute: who rang, whether they are a new or existing client, what it is about, how urgent it is and what to do next.

So instead of a missed call from an unknown number, you get something like: "New enquiry, contract dispute with a supplier, response due next Wednesday, best on 0420 111 333 after 2pm." You can decide in ten seconds whether it needs a call back today.

The assistant does not give advice. It takes the details and tells the caller someone will be in touch. If a caller asks whether they are speaking to a person, it tells them it is an AI assistant.

Urgent matters and existing clients

Some calls cannot wait until the end of the meeting. Decide in advance what counts as urgent for your firm, such as a same-day deadline, a settlement problem or a client in a difficult situation.

With AfterTone you can mark a colleague as the transfer contact, and the assistant can put urgent callers through to them live. It can also flag the call as urgent in the summary, and on the Email + SMS plan text you straight away. You can add key clients as VIP callers so their calls are always flagged.

When an existing client rings, the assistant notes what they tell it about their matter, so you can call back already knowing what it is about.

Deal with sales calls once

Sales calls take up more of a small firm's day than most people realise. Tell the assistant how to treat them: take a short message, or politely decline. Either way, they stop interrupting you.

A simple routine for a busy day

  • Between meetings: read the summaries, newest and most urgent first.
  • Same day: return new enquiries with a deadline and any urgent existing-client calls.
  • Next day: routine client questions and calls from other professionals.
  • Never: sales calls you have told the assistant to decline.

The short version

  • New matters arrive by phone, often while you are with a client.
  • New enquiries are the most valuable and the most time-sensitive calls.
  • Ask every caller the same four questions, and never give advice on the phone.
  • Route urgent calls to a colleague, and stop sales calls interrupting you.
  • Return calls with the context already in hand.

The client in the room deserves your full attention. The next client deserves a prompt, professional answer. With the right setup, both get one.

See how it works for firms: AfterTone for legal and accounting, or build your assistant free and we will ring you so you can hear it.

Try AfterTone free

Build your assistant in three minutes and hear it answer a real call. No card needed.

Build your free assistant

Need help?